Carry-In Tire Guide

Affiliate disclosure: some links on this site may later earn us a commission at no cost to you. We have not been approved by any affiliate program yet, so every retailer link is a plain link right now. Details.

Tire shops that mount tires bought online in Cary, NC

Prices checked Oct 21, 2026 · 6 shops

All 6 Cary tire shops we found publish an install price for tires shipped to them through SimpleTire, from $26.50/tire (2 shops) to $46.50/tire (Omiya Sports Inc), with mounting, balancing, valve stems, disposal and a TPMS reset included. None publishes a price for tires you buy elsewhere and carry in yourself, so call for an out-the-door quote first.

Install prices and policies

“Ship-to-shop” prices only apply when you order through that retailer and have the tires shipped to the shop. They are not quotes for tires you bring in yourself.
SimpleTire prices include mounting, balancing, rubber valve stems, disposal and a TPMS reset (not a new sensor kit), with a 4-tire minimum, according to each shop's SimpleTire page. SimpleTire adds that replacement TPMS sensors and oversized-vehicle charges may cost extra.
We took every price from the shop's own SimpleTire page, not SimpleTire's Cary city listing, which shows different (lower) figures.
The shop list comes from SimpleTire's installer network. Other Cary shops may also mount tires; we list only shops we could source.

Shop	Carry-in (tires from anywhere)	Ship-to-shop: SimpleTire orders	Ship-to-shop: Tire Rack orders
Atlantic Tire (1380 NW Maynard Rd)	Call — not published	$26.50/tire simpletire.com, checked Oct 21, 2026 (page fetched)	Not listed
Atlantic Tire (360 Ashville Ave)	Call — not published	$26.50/tire simpletire.com, checked Oct 21, 2026 (page fetched)	Not listed
Mr. Tire Auto Service Centers (1811 N Harrison Ave)	Call — not published	$35.99/tire simpletire.com, checked Oct 21, 2026 (page fetched)	Not listed
Mr. Tire Auto Service Centers (2315 Davis Dr)	Call — not published	$35.99/tire simpletire.com, checked Oct 21, 2026 (page fetched)	Not listed
Crossroads Auto Service	Call — not published	$39.45/tire simpletire.com, checked Oct 21, 2026 (page fetched)	Not listed
Omiya Sports Inc	Call — not published	$46.50/tire simpletire.com, checked Oct 21, 2026 (page fetched)	Not listed

Report a wrong price: tell us the shop, the right price, and where you saw it.

Shops

Atlantic Tire (1380 NW Maynard Rd)

1380 NW Maynard Rd, Cary, NC 27513
(919) 319-1614

Tires you bring in: Not published. Price: Call — not published

SimpleTire orders: $26.50/tire. Includes mount, balance, rubber valve stems, disposal, TPMS reset; min 4 tires; rims 13–22″ Source: simpletire.com, checked Oct 21, 2026 (page fetched)
Address and phone come from the shop's SimpleTire page.

Atlantic Tire (360 Ashville Ave)

360 Ashville Ave, Cary, NC 27518
(919) 803-6159

Tires you bring in: Not published. Price: Call — not published

SimpleTire orders: $26.50/tire. Includes mount, balance, rubber valve stems, disposal, TPMS reset; min 4 tires; rims 13–22″ Source: simpletire.com, checked Oct 21, 2026 (page fetched)
Address and phone come from the shop's SimpleTire page.

Mr. Tire Auto Service Centers (1811 N Harrison Ave)

1811 N Harrison Ave, Cary, NC 27513
(919) 677-0800 · Website

Tires you bring in: Not published. Price: Call — not published

SimpleTire orders: $35.99/tire. Includes mount, balance, rubber valve stems, disposal, TPMS reset; min 4 tires; rims 6–24″ Source: simpletire.com, checked Oct 21, 2026 (page fetched)
Address and phone come from the shop's SimpleTire page.

Mr. Tire Auto Service Centers (2315 Davis Dr)

2315 Davis Dr, Cary, NC 27519
(984) 687-1016 · Website

Tires you bring in: Not published. Price: Call — not published

SimpleTire orders: $35.99/tire. Includes mount, balance, rubber valve stems, disposal, TPMS reset; min 4 tires; rims 6–24″ Source: simpletire.com, checked Oct 21, 2026 (page fetched)
Address and phone come from the shop's SimpleTire page.

Crossroads Auto Service

1720 Walnut St, Cary, NC 27511
(919) 467-0803

Tires you bring in: Not published. Price: Call — not published

SimpleTire orders: $39.45/tire. Includes mount, balance, rubber valve stems, disposal, TPMS reset; min 4 tires; rims 13–22″ Source: simpletire.com, checked Oct 21, 2026 (page fetched)
Address and phone come from the shop's SimpleTire page.

Omiya Sports Inc

508 E Chatham St, Cary, NC 27511
(919) 469-8665

Tires you bring in: Not published. Price: Call — not published

SimpleTire orders: $46.50/tire. Includes mount, balance, rubber valve stems, disposal, TPMS reset; min 4 tires; rims 13–22″ Source: simpletire.com, checked Oct 21, 2026 (page fetched)
Address and phone come from the shop's SimpleTire page.

Chain policies

Costco: No. Costco installs only tires bought at Costco, and only for members.
Discount Tire (coming soon)
Walmart Auto Care (coming soon)
Firestone / Tires Plus (coming soon)

FAQ

Will tire shops in Cary mount tires I bought online?

Usually, but none of the 6 Cary shops we checked publishes a carry-in policy or price. 6 of them publish a price when the tires ship to them through SimpleTire. For tires bought anywhere else, call and ask for the out-the-door price per tire.

What does it cost to have online tires installed in Cary?

Published ship-to-shop prices run from $26.50/tire (2 shops) to $46.50/tire (Omiya Sports Inc) for SimpleTire orders, with valve stems, disposal and a TPMS reset included. Carry-in prices aren't published.

Will Costco install tires I bought somewhere else?

No. Costco's Tire Center FAQ says it “will only install Costco-purchased tires,” and its tire disclaimers say it won't service tires bought by non-members. See our Costco page.

What should I ask when I call?

Ask: Do you install tires I bring in? What's the per-tire price for mount and balance? Are valve stems, a TPMS service kit, disposal and any shop fee extra? Do you charge more for low-profile, run-flat or large tires? Do I need an appointment?

Nearby cities