Prices checked Oct 23, 2026 · 19 shops
All 19 Madison tire shops we found publish an install price for tires shipped to them through SimpleTire, from $34.00/tire (Black Label Auto) to $52.99/tire (13 shops), with mounting, balancing, valve stems, disposal and a TPMS reset included. None publishes a price for tires you buy elsewhere and carry in yourself, so call for an out-the-door quote first.
| Shop | Carry-in (tires from anywhere) | Ship-to-shop: SimpleTire orders | Ship-to-shop: Tire Rack orders |
|---|---|---|---|
| Black Label Auto | Call — not published | $34.00/tire simpletire.com, checked Oct 23, 2026 (page fetched) |
Not listed |
| Firestone Complete Auto Care | Call — not published | $48.99/tire simpletire.com, checked Oct 23, 2026 (page fetched) |
Not listed |
| Meineke Car Care Centers | Call — not published | $48.99/tire simpletire.com, checked Oct 23, 2026 (page fetched) |
Not listed |
| Meineke - Madison #1649 | Call — not published | $48.99/tire simpletire.com, checked Oct 23, 2026 (page fetched) |
Not listed |
| Tires Plus Total Car Care | Call — not published | $48.99/tire simpletire.com, checked Oct 23, 2026 (page fetched) |
Not listed |
| TONYS AUTO REPAIR | Call — not published | $48.99/tire simpletire.com, checked Oct 23, 2026 (page fetched) |
Not listed |
| Capitol Tire And Service | Call — not published | $52.99/tire simpletire.com, checked Oct 23, 2026 (page fetched) |
Not listed |
| Car Care Clinic | Call — not published | $52.99/tire simpletire.com, checked Oct 23, 2026 (page fetched) |
Not listed |
| CHET'S CAR CARE CENTER, INC. | Call — not published | $52.99/tire simpletire.com, checked Oct 23, 2026 (page fetched) |
Not listed |
| Clausen Automotive | Call — not published | $52.99/tire simpletire.com, checked Oct 23, 2026 (page fetched) |
Not listed |
| Dave's Auto Service | Call — not published | $52.99/tire simpletire.com, checked Oct 23, 2026 (page fetched) |
Not listed |
| Don the Car Care Man | Call — not published | $52.99/tire simpletire.com, checked Oct 23, 2026 (page fetched) |
Not listed |
| Porsche Madison - Service Center | Call — not published | $52.99/tire simpletire.com, checked Oct 23, 2026 (page fetched) |
Not listed |
| ROB'S AUTOMOTIVE, LLC | Call — not published | $52.99/tire simpletire.com, checked Oct 23, 2026 (page fetched) |
Not listed |
| Rosen Nissan of Madison Service | Call — not published | $52.99/tire simpletire.com, checked Oct 23, 2026 (page fetched) |
Not listed |
| Smart Toyota Service | Call — not published | $52.99/tire simpletire.com, checked Oct 23, 2026 (page fetched) |
Not listed |
| West Town Monona Tire | Call — not published | $52.99/tire simpletire.com, checked Oct 23, 2026 (page fetched) |
Not listed |
| Westside Service Center | Call — not published | $52.99/tire simpletire.com, checked Oct 23, 2026 (page fetched) |
Not listed |
| Zimbrick Buick GMC Eastside Service Center | Call — not published | $52.99/tire simpletire.com, checked Oct 23, 2026 (page fetched) |
Not listed |
Report a wrong price: tell us the shop, the right price, and where you saw it.
1425 Gilson St, Madison, WI 53715
(608) 422-2609
Tires you bring in: Not published. Price: Call — not published
7105 Mineral Point Rd, Madison, WI 53717
(608) 833-6161
Tires you bring in: Not published. Price: Call — not published
4008 Milwaukee St, Madison, WI 53714
(608) 244-3479
Tires you bring in: Not published. Price: Call — not published
437 Commerce Drive, Madison, WI 53719
(608) 677-6386
Tires you bring in: Not published. Price: Call — not published
1450 MacArthur Rd, Madison, WI 53714
(608) 620-7786
Tires you bring in: Not published. Price: Call — not published
3110 Watford Way, Madison, WI 53713
(608) 770-7773
Tires you bring in: Not published. Price: Call — not published
5610 Odana Rd, Madison, WI 53719
(608) 271-9009
Tires you bring in: Not published. Price: Call — not published
2733 University Ave, Madison, WI 53705
(608) 233-4600
Tires you bring in: Not published. Price: Call — not published
2020 Aberg Ave, Madison, WI 53704
(608) 249-9887
Tires you bring in: Not published. Price: Call — not published
2118 S Stoughton Rd, Madison, WI 53716
(608) 221-8321
Tires you bring in: Not published. Price: Call — not published
4822 Pflaum Rd, Madison, WI 53718
(608) 240-9000
Tires you bring in: Not published. Price: Call — not published
7869 Big Sky Dr, Madison, WI 53719
(608) 833-4646
Tires you bring in: Not published. Price: Call — not published
2300 Rimrock Rd, Madison, WI 53713
(608) 258-4000
Tires you bring in: Not published. Price: Call — not published
5506 County Road Cv, Madison, WI 53704
(608) 441-5516
Tires you bring in: Not published. Price: Call — not published
2510 W Beltline Hwy, Madison, WI 53713
(608) 471-7552
Tires you bring in: Not published. Price: Call — not published
5901 Odana Rd, Madison, WI 53719
(608) 275-7808
Tires you bring in: Not published. Price: Call — not published
453 S Gammon Rd, Madison, WI 53719
(608) 833-1735
Tires you bring in: Not published. Price: Call — not published
2014 Freeport Rd, Madison, WI 53711
(608) 271-6861
Tires you bring in: Not published. Price: Call — not published
5402 High Crossing Blvd, Madison, WI 53718
(608) 316-8890
Tires you bring in: Not published. Price: Call — not published
Usually, but none of the 19 Madison shops we checked publishes a carry-in policy or price. 19 of them publish a price when the tires ship to them through SimpleTire. For tires bought anywhere else, call and ask for the out-the-door price per tire.
Published ship-to-shop prices run from $34.00/tire (Black Label Auto) to $52.99/tire (13 shops) for SimpleTire orders, with valve stems, disposal and a TPMS reset included. Carry-in prices aren't published.
No. Costco's Tire Center FAQ says it “will only install Costco-purchased tires,” and its tire disclaimers say it won't service tires bought by non-members. See our Costco page.
Ask: Do you install tires I bring in? What's the per-tire price for mount and balance? Are valve stems, a TPMS service kit, disposal and any shop fee extra? Do you charge more for low-profile, run-flat or large tires? Do I need an appointment?